EUROPE & SOVEREIGN
DEBT DISTRESS
BACKGROUND ON DECONSTRUCTION
◄$$$ EUROPE STANDS AT HIGH RISK
FOR SOVEREIGN DEBT. THIS HIGHLY IMPORTANT TOPIC REQUIRES A
PREFACE. RISK ABOUNDS. POSTURING IS WIDESPREAD. AN AGENDA
IS BEING WORKED. MANY PUNDITS MIGHT BE WAY OFF IN THEIR ANALYSIS
OF THE SITUATION. GERMANY IS IN FULL CONTROL,
BUT MUST GIVE THE APPEARANCE OF TRYING TO HALT THE DEFAULTS
SO EAGERLY DESIRED. $$$
Consider the Wall Street Journal. No slouch as a journal,
but perhaps not with a resident European expertise. A handful
of keen experts aids the Hat Trick Letter. They counter the
conventional viewpoints. The WSJ claims half of the 16 Eurozone
countries are at 'High Risk' in terms of the sustainability
of their public finances. Read: their sovereign debt viability.
The Euro Central Bank has an unforgiving charter, since new
and not entirely federalist. The common Euro currency was
a bad idea, whose time has come to conclusion. Severe seemingly
merciless changes are to come swiftly. Ewald Nowotny is the
Austrian member of the Governing Council to the EuroCB. He
said in a December interview, "One has to be very
clear. The ECB has no mandate or intention to take into account
the situation of a specific country, especially not with regard
to public finances." The tale of the European housecleaning
and fat carving begins in January with Greece, which will submit
its fiscal overhaul. Their defiance seeps through the pages
onto the streets. The timespan for the altered European Monetary
Union (EMU: region sharing the Euro currency) will not take
two years as the WSJ claims, but less, as events will unfold
very rapidly. See the Wall Street Journal article (CLICK HERE).
The Wall Street Journal put out the above clumsy graph, which
exemplifies the INCORRECT risk assessment that floats in the
financial press networks. The graph is way off, with half
the nations improperly classified. Focus on the bigger and
more important nations that will shape the future course of
Europe. Corrections come with the contributions
of certain knowledgable and reliable European sources. Comments
display the misconceptions, each to cause some alarm if not
shock. The graph shows high risk nations in red. Italy
and Portugal are dead in their debt situation, each deserving
red like Greece, Spain, and Ireland. The Netherlands is shown at high
risk red, but it is at zero risk and deserves green, a gross
error. Belgium
is shown at medium risk in blue, but it is at zero risk and
deserves green. The entire Benelux group
is strong. Germany and the Netherlands are the powerhouses keeping the Euro
currency and European Union afloat with their trade surpluses.
Germany
warrants a green code. The WSJ has almost nothing right
on the national map.
A short comment came from a German banker contact, with an
excellent track record. He said, "The EURO will die
a sudden death, much faster than the USDollar, since the underlying
economics of the EURO are only political in nature. The coming
adjustment will be hard and violent. We expect things to come
to a boiling point and blow up in 2010. The US$
will die its own death, with death being redefined multiple
times while that happens. Like going from Used Cars to Pre-Owned
Cars to Re-Certified Cars. It is bullshxx window dressing
to camouflage the demise until all snaps and comes crashing
down." Another short comment came from a second German
banker and former corporate conglomerate executive, one with
past ties in advisory capacity to the Euro Central Bank. Dieter
Spethmann said, "Problems lie much deeper. Casino
capitalism enriches some but makes many poor and fills nobody's
stomach. Europe needs as the United States does a new understanding
for the financing of their Realwirtschaft (Real Economy).
The world needs altogether a new Bretton Woods III,
which implies flexible exchange rates and the legal obligation
to use them for revaluation in case of sustained current
account surpluses. Credit needs new definitions and new certainties,
[enforced and dictated by] Gold."
The German political and banking leaders are walking a narrow
risky path to handle the situation diplomatically and with
a deft hand, so as not to inflame emotional reactions or even
national retaliation. My personal belief is that Germany
wants to carve off Portugal, Italy, Greece, and Spain from
the shared Euro currency usage, to permit them to return to
their former domestic currencies, to go through the debt default
and restructure process, and to QUIT relying upon German welfare
program to sustain their undeservedly high standard of living
at heavy German expense. They will therefore give the
appearance of offering more aid than is delivered in a delicate
situation. Chancellor Angela Merkel said the mounting Greek
budget deficit risks hurting the Euro, claiming the currency
faces a very difficult phase. Merkel has openly questioned
the fiscal discipline of other countries using the Euro currency,
like with pension policies. The first test case and breakdown
clearly comes in Greece.
For an excellent review, background, and brief analysis of
the European financial and sovereign crisis, see the Kitco
article entitled "The Euro/Dollar Dance"
by Sol Palha (CLICK HERE). The author distinguished
himself in my view by correctly forecasting the paradoxical
rise in the USDollar that was seen in autumn 2008, based upon
derivative contract and debt liquidation, the beginning phase
of the virtual death of the US financial structural foundation.
He received little accolade or credit, since his description
of the unfolding events was laid out in the year 2003.
INSANE MEDICINE & DEBT DEATH SPIRAL
◄$$$ SLOW DEATH COMES TO SOUTHERN
EUROPE AS GREAT CHANGES DEVELOP. THE DEBT RATING AGENCIES
ARE DOING THEIR JOB FINALLY. IRONY COMES AS E.U. DIRECTIVES
FOLLOW I.M.F. DEADLY DISASTROUS COUNSEL, WHICH THE DEBT RATING
AGENCIES MUST HIGHLIGHT AS DESTRUCTIVE. DEBT ROLLOVER WILL
NOT HAPPEN. IN ORDER TO ACHIEVE A RECOVERY WITH STABILITY,
A DEFIANT STANCE MUST BE PURSUED THAT REVERTS TO THE FORMER
DOMESTIC CURRENCY. $$$
Moodys has stated that Greece
and Portugal
might face a terminal situation. In my view, all four of the
PIGS nations (Portugal, Italy,
Greece,
and Spain) face a certain death
in the sense of a sovereign debt default, and forced radical
restructure. The first will be Greece,
the second Italy.
Moodys focuses on the Greek and Portuguese economies as facing
a 'Slow Death' in their words. The nations dedicate a higher
proportion of wealth to paying off debt while investors demand
a premium to hold their bonds, according to Moodys Investors
Service. That means the debt ratio to economic size is higher
and bond yields must be set higher. Their commission forecast
stated that the UKGovt debt burden will amount to 80% of GDP
this year, the Italian Govt debt to 117% of GDP, and the Greek
Govt debt 125%. The high risk for Greece is reflected in a higher
cost of their sovereign debt insurance premium. Insurance
costs against a Greek Govt default leapt to a record after
the Moodys assessment. See the Bloomberg article (CLICK HERE).
The heavy lifting on federal response, urged by the European
Union, comes from typical tired toxic responses that follow
the failed IMF guidelines such as tax hikes, spending cuts,
and reduced programs both of social and infrastructure.
Unfortunately, they are utterly disastrous without a single
past historical precedent of success. The result is a downward
death spiral for nations that accept the IMF-style ruinous
medicine. Ireland has done so, and should be watched as
ruin is almost assured. Since the nations under distress cannot
devalue the common currency, the government debt remains unchanged
and burdensome. The usual stupid suicidal medicine is reduced
federal spending, higher interest rates, broad job cuts, reduced
projects, but without the required stimulus from a devalued
currency. The lack of currency discount means both the
debt remains impossible to pay, and exports cannot be revived
when urgently needed to bring in foreign capital and cash
flow. The higher interest rates restrict capital formation
and job stability. The reduction in projects and worker income
puts the brakes on the economy and imposes greater strain
on the federal governments. Federal deficits rise drastically.
The nation is crippled further, to the point that the austerity
measures eliminate its ability to repay the debt. The IMF
directives basically drive the nation into ruin, probably
the actual plan. One last piece to the IMF poison pill.
The interest charges imposed for the IMF loan act like draining
blood from a prone patient in the hospital bed, after the
accepted medicine sends it from the sick ward to the intensive
care room.
Evans-Pritchard calls the standard IMF toxic reform approach
'Medieval Leech Cures' very appropriately and colorfully.
Mark Weisbrot from the think
tank Center for Economic & Policy
Research released a report in 2009 from a study of 41 nations
following IMF reforms. The study concluded that the IMF
austere policies did more damage than help the affected economies.
Marshall Auerbach rivals Evans-Pritchard in colorful metaphors.
When describing the IMF damage done to former Soviet states,
Auerbach said "The West has viewed them as economic
oysters to be broken up to indebt them in order to extract
interest charges and capital gains, leaving them empty shells."
The IMF practices have been to extract capital and weaken
the economic engines, precisely the opposite of what is urgently
needed for a distressed nation. Unlike a bankruptcy process,
the IMF orders passage through a slaughterhouse. In my
view, the IMF and World Bank have a very clear unmistakable
track record of causing ruin toward maintenance of the US
and UK in dominant exploitative roles. The World
Court should step in to declare the IMF as criminal, commiting
crimes against humanity in economic chambers. A revolt is
due. It might come from a defiant Greece, or possibly Latvia. The key to recovery is to refuse the IMF
reforms, to return to the former domestic currency, to devalue
it right away, to force deep foreirgn debt reductions, to
convert commercial contracts, and to instill a positive psychology
at the national level. The nationalism can be set on a positive
course for reconstruction, or it can turn ugly and destructive
as it results in riots and anger directed at the IMF or EU,
even its own leadership that accepts the restrictive reforms
based in a tradition of stupidity. Some precedent exists for
defiance in a successful path, such as Argentina in the last 20 years.
Defiance must come against the lunatic economic grenades tossed into
distressed nations and their financial structures. Auerbach
suggest defiance in a formula: 1) do not communicate with
creditors, 2) declare banks insolvent with debt converted
to equity and deposits fully guaranteed in the local currency,
and 3) offer local currency jobs with health care insurance.
Evans-Pritchard suggests that Greece break the death spiral
by restoring its drachma currency, devalue it immediately,
switch Euro debt to drachma debt, and restructure foreign
contracts. What he described is a bankruptcy restructure,
as opposed to the IMF toxic treatment and slaughter. See an
excellent article by Ellen Brown entitled "European
Union Debt Revolt" on Market Oracle (CLICK HERE). We could soon
see the global discredit of the IMF on reform counsel. They
are but a hammer used by the US-UK field bosses to kill nations.
LEGAL BASIS FOR EXPULSION
◄$$$ THE EUROPEAN UNION IS PREPARING THE LEGAL BASIS
TO REMOVE GREECE,
ITS WEAKEST LINK, ACTUALLY ITS BROKEN LINK. A QUICK SURVEY
OF MANY ISSUES FILLS THE BACKDROP. GREECE
WILL NOT BE RESCUED. ITS HERITAGE HAS ALMOST NO BLOODLINE
LINKAGE. $$$
The Euro Central Bank prepares legal ground for dismissal
of Greece
as the crisis in Athens escalates toward an inevitable climax. The
Dubai debt default
set the stage for debt intolerance. As Greek Govt debt
will not be refinanced and rolled over, a default will occur,
even orchestrated. Greece will be the first nation
in the European Union (EU) to abandon the Euro currency, in
retaliation for refusal by the Euro Central Bank to refinance
their debt. Bear in mind that on a tribal hereditary basis,
Greece is not a Germanic or Latin nation by blood.
It lies on the periphery of Europe. It
has no traditional bank heritage. It has no vital industry.
It thus serves as a perfect test case for default, dismissal,
contractual rework, and more. Its failure and restructure
will offer a model workbook written for application
elsewhere, immediately. Plenty of hypocrisy to go around here,
since the Maastricht
treaty calls for limits on federal deficits and total government
debt. Violations are aplenty within the EU.
Ambrose Evans-Pritchard wrote an interesting essay on the
topic, worthy of comment. He states from the start that Europe
is preparing the course for exit from the union in urgency.
Withdrawal and expulsion from the EU and EMU will go hand
in hand, as abandoned currency usage requires exit from the
political structure as well. He is implicitly critical of
the EU lawyers, when he wrote, "The author makes a
string of vaulting, Jesuitical, and mischievous claims, as
EU lawyers often do. Half a century of ever-closer union has
created a 'new legal order' that transcends a 'largely obsolete
concept of sovereignty' and imposes a 'permanent limitation'
on the state rights. Those who suspect that European Court has the power pretensions of the
Medieval Papacy will find plenty to validate their fears in
this astonishing text. Crucially, he argues that Eurozone
exit entails expulsion from the European Union as well.
All EU members must take part in EMU (except Britain
and Denmark,
with opt-outs). This is a warning shot for Greece,
Portugal,
Ireland, and Spain. If they fail to marshal public support
for draconian austerity, they risk being cast into Icelandic
oblivion. Or for Greece,
back into the clammy embrace of Asia
Minor. ECB chief Jean-Claude Trichet upped the ante, warning
that the bank would not bend its collateral rules to support
Greek debt." The Euro Central Bank could not be more
clear.
Trichet signaled clearly that the Greek Govt debt will not
be aided, certain to default. The Hellenic Socialists (PASOK)
from Athens endured a shock recently when ¬1.6billion
(=£1.4B, =US$2.2B) in Greek debt auction fell on its face.
The interest rate on 6-month notes rose to 1.38%, versus 0.59%
only one month ago. The yield on 10-year Greek Eurobonds
reached 6%, as the spread ballooning to 270 basis points above
benchmark German Bunds. The breakdown will come from the
premium paid on short-term borrowing costs immediately. The
nation of Greece
must raise ¬54 billion this year, with a big front load in
the first half of 2010. Moodys regards Greece
and Portugal
at grave risk from rising interest costs and debt refinance.
Severe stress fractures are likely next. The fix will be like
carving off the fat on a slab of steak, from the edge of the
EU core. As debt within their banking systems is written down
and losses are absorbed, great stress will come to their entire
financial structures, exacerbating the sovereign debt into
a collapse. Restructure will follow.
Many fallacious arguments are built upon the wrong premise
that the German juggernaut will rescue reckless Club Med nations
like it did for East
Germany. NOT TRUE! The bloodlines were
strong from the old German Federation to East German brothers,
under the Soviet thumb for 40 years. In every conversation
made by the Jackass with German natives centered on why take
on such a huge Reunification project with such huge costs,
they all replied the same, saying "they are Germans;
they are our brothers" in clear fashion. The Greeks
are nobody's brothers, and the Southern Europe Latin nations
have angered the Germans to the extreme. In fact, something
is rarely mentioned in the press but always cited by my German
contacts. The Southern Latin nations have cost Germany
$300 billion per year for ten straight years, thus reducing
the German standard of living and adding to their debt burden.
That is $3 trillion welfare cost to German in the experimental
ruinous decade. They are sick of it, and finally will carve
off the Latin fat and remove the drag to Berlin. The legal basis is being forged to do precisely that.
Evans-Pritchard points out that in Western Europe only Greece treats the military
budget as a state secret. Rating agencies guess it is a ruinous
5% of GDP. The country of Greece
has 1700 battle tanks, 420 combat jets, and eight submarines
in contributions to NATO, with an 11 million population. Maybe
they can sell half this military arsenal to China
and raise significant funds. They border Turkey, whose natives look to a different deity.
Next comes the climax events with retrenchment, all direct
consequences to faulty IMF pathways. Evans-Pritchard wrote,
"But devaluation is ruled out. Greece must take the pain,
without the cure. The policy is conceptually foolish and arguably
cynical. It is to bleed a society in order to uphold the ideology
of the European Project." The Greek debt spiral will
end in default, a situation clear to anyone with common sense,
which excludes most mainstream economists. The Greek national
debt will be 120% of GDP this year. Standard & Poors expects
it will reach 138% by 2012. A harsh spending reduction
and tax increase without any lower interest rate or currency
devaulation will cause tax revenues to collapse, without any
shadow of doubt. Debt will rise higher on a shrinking
economic base, which does not include any semblance of strong
export trade. Greece
is caught in a vise. Labor minister Andreas Loverdos claimed
unemployment would reach a million this year, equal to 22%.
Some believe he broadcast the forecast with a hint of menace,
as if he wanted Europe to squirm. See
the UK Telegraph article (CLICK HERE).
Two can play brinkmanship. The EU from Brussels,
run by Berlin bankers, will just say
NO to Greece. The Greek leaders
might just say NO to the kooky killer reforms. Prepare for
debt default, the next sovereign debt default after Iceland.
MODEL FOR ADDITIONAL EXPULSIONS
◄$$$ THE E.U. WILL NOT BAIL OUT GREECE. IN FACT, IT WILL BECOME A TEST CASE, EVEN
TO CREATE A MODEL FOR IMITATION IN ITALY,
SPAIN,
AND PORTUGAL. EUROPE WILL STUMBLE ALONG AS IT PRESERVES ITS CORE. $$$
The Euro currency seems to be a thermometer for EU fever
over the Greek Govt debt situation. A sudden tumble was seen
in the Euro after comments came from a Euro Central Bank executive
board member Jurgen Stark. He stated clearly that the European
Union would not save Greece from its fiscal problems. A tactical approach
seems clear. Watch the highest leaders address larger problems
but speak promisingly, while lower officials speak more plainly
and realistically. That way the leaders can lay responsibility
for decisions upon expert counselors who make decisions impartially.
The Euro currency soon recovered though, when fickle investors
combed through a report that showed the Eurozone service sector
was expanding at its fastest pace in more than two years.
Stark is the ECB chief economist and the German member
on the bank's inner council to the central bank. Read:
the most powerful voice on the EuroCB. He stood on legal ground
when he called Greece's problems entirely home grown, not
having met the terms required to trigger the rescue mechanism
under EU treaty law. A clear legal stipulation refers to aid
to be limited to countries that face severe difficulties 'beyond
their own control' ominously. So weak industry, lack of export
trade, and heavy social network costs constitute a home grown
problem. That makes sense. It will build a platform for rejection
apparently. Stark said, "The Treaties set out a 'no
bail-out' clause, and the rules will be respected. This is
crucial for guaranteeing the future of a monetary union among
sovereign states with national budgets. Markets are deluding
themselves if they think that the other member states will
at a certain point dip their hands into their wallets to save
Greece."
See the Financial Times article (CLICK HERE).
Germany
could not be more clear.
A key global banker contact shared some comments. His strongest
ties are from Central Europe with Swiss
and German bankers. He shared what he believed to be The Plan
in the following. The European Union will not break. Instead
the EU will consolidate into a strong core. It will force
a currency realignment to deal with regional differences.
The Greek experiment in default will provide much useful information,
employed in a guinea pig role. The nation will be used to
lever its relatively small deficits into a devalued currency.
They will revert to the drachma, whence they came. The Germans
will no longer tolerate carrying via subsidies the debt burden
of inefficient and deficit ridden Southern
Europe nations. Germans are angry at their lost purchasing
power and have tired of pulling the European load. The Lira
currency is consistenly cited on transactions and contracts
and will return to Italy. In fact, immediately
after the Greek debt default has concluded, Italy will be forced into a debt default of its
own, and the path will be followed from the manual written
from the learned Greek experience. From Italy
the default path will include Spain
and Portugal,
post haste. He mentioned how some learning from the Greek
breakdown is necessary. My interpretation is that much must
be monitored on the uncertain outcomes regarding discounts
for defaulted bonds, for choosing banks to survive, for reworked
contracts in the reverted domestic currency, and even damage
from civil response in riots as nationalism is displayed in
stark terms. This learning will write the manual applied to
Italy right
away, then Spain
and Portugal.
Enormous differentiation exists among European nations that
render impossible a common currency, seen vividly in non-homogeneous
EuroBonds. For two years, reported by the Hat Trick Letter,
the German type EuroBond has not been interchangeable with
other national EuroBonds. That has been my premise for establishment
of two Euro currencies, or a Core Euro currency and reversion
to former currencies. The other nations differ greatly
from Germany
in trade surplus, federal deficits, interest rates, price
inflation, productivity, and tax structure. Cultural contrasts
expose work ethic differences and tolerance to corruption
also. The same global banker contact coldly stated something
that exposes the lack of heritage connections, when he said
nobody in Central Europe cares about
the PIGS nations. He fully expects France
to follow the default path of the PIGS nations, as he called
the doomed group of nations the F-PIGS. France
is unique, however, as it owns an extensive nuclear weapon
arsenal, and more importantly the Bundesbank owns 95% of the
French Govt debt. He anticipates France will be kept under
the German aegis of protection, spared the shame of default,
but only at a hidden cost paid behind the curtain. The French
will be denied a prominent role, since so utterly obnoxious
when given power, in his opinion. The generous global banker
made a few general Euro comments. He was harshly critical
of EuroCB head Trichet, who has led the Euro currency into
an unsustainable role of serving as the global secondary reserve
currency, not the original intention. The inevitability of
trading Euros in US$ terms via heavy FOREX trading platforms
has caused undesired problems. See the German export reaction
to the 160 Euro exchange rate peak 18 months ago. The Euro
was not designed for such a reserve role in actual structure.
The EuroCB was not designed to provide aid and stimulus or
to promote growth, but rather to promote price stability.
It was not designed to respond to regional differences. In
fact, my added comment is that late in the generational cycle,
any currency utilized as a secondary reserve will suffer from
primary Competitive Currency War damage. Its exchange rate
will rise to the point of inflicting notable damage to the
resident export industry.
NEXT FALLOUT ZONES
◄$$$ SPANISH DEBT IS A DEFAULT READY TO HAPPEN. ITS
DEBT LEVELS SHOULD DOUBLE QUICKLY. VOICES WITHIN SPAIN
EXPECT GERMANY
TO SAVE THEIR SKIN, BUT THEY WILL NOT. $$$
Alvaro Guzman is Managing Partner of Bestinver, a leading
fund in performance. His words carry weight. The crash
of a Spanish real estate market, which caught banks with ¬324
billion (=US$462 billion) in loans to developers, will limit
economic growth and tax revenues, perhaps forcing an eventual
bailout of the country by Germany, according to Guzman. He
describes rows of skeletons in the Spanish closets. He said,
"We are very pessimistic on Spain because we think there
are still skeletons to come out of the cupboards, basically
marking to market the true value of real estate on the balance
sheets of the banks. It is not just the banks we [exited from
investments] but anything that has a Spanish cyclical component."
Guzman acknowledges that Spanish debt levels could quickly
rise, even though they currently compare favorably to countries
like Greece.
Spain
stands almost entirely alone in the lunatic practice of NOT
writing down bank loans backed by property, since the collateral
properties have not come down in price much at all. Big
losses come, most likely born by the Spanish Govt, thus rapidly
lifting the sovereign debt level. He makes the assumption
that Germany
will ride in like a white knight and help Spain.
He might be in for a shock. Germany
has helped them for a full decade, and has reached its limit.
Standard & Poors lowered its outlook on Spanish Govt debt
to a AA+ credit rating on December 9th. The S&P credit
analyst Trevor Cullinan expects their debt burden to quickly
more than double to as much as 90% of gross domestic product.
Guzman is but one in a crowd negative on Spain.
Budget and debt finance concerns that damage Greek bonds are
spreading to other Southern European economies. Jim O'Neill
is chief global economist at Goldman Sachs. He is watching
whether further damage to the Greek credit ratings sparks
a 'cascading game' where the credit market attacks Spain
and Portugal
in quick succession. See the Bloomberg article (CLICK HERE).
The cascade is exactly my forecast.
◄$$$ FITCH WARNS FRANCE
AND ENGLAND
RISK AAA RATING. SOVEREIGN DEBT DOMINOES ARE MOVING INTO POSITION
FOR A STRING OF FAILURES. NO NATION IS SACRED, EVEN ENGLAND. $$$
Debt ratings agency Fitch has warned that Britain and France risk losing their AAA rating. The delivered
message was an important shot across the credit bow of two
leading nations. Fitch said that none of the arguably benchmark
AAA states (leading industrial nations) can safely rely upon
their top debt rating for much longer. Emphasized was
what they called 'unpleasant fiscal arithmetic' faced by states
across the Old World. More directly,
Fitch forecasted that sovereign debt in both Britain and France
will reach 90% of GDP by year 2011, higher than the 80% level
held by Japan when it lost its AAA
rating earlier this decade. See the UK Telegraph article (CLICK
HERE).
FROM THE HERETIC HIGH PRIEST
◄$$$ MILTON FRIEDMAN PITCHED IN WITH THOUGHTS ON THE
EURO CURRENCY RISK OF FRACTURE. HE CORRECTLY FORESAW ITS DOOMED
FATE IN TEN YEARS TIME. IT WAS BADLY DESIGNED AND STANDS AS
UNWORKABLE IN A HETEROGENEOUS EUROPE MIX. $$$
Milton Friedman is responsible for the Quantitative Theory
of money, as response to demand for money results in altered
supply in optimally unregulated markets. The current financial
situation is somewhat an extension of his espoused principals.
The Supply Side economists argued for de-regulation, but in
doing so they opened the doors wide for corruption, which
Friedman almost never touches, not even remotely. Where is
his chapter on syndicates and criminal control of the USDept
Treasury? Nowhere! Friedman and Samuelson have served as
the two high priests to justify ruinous economic ideology
for a generation, as every Ponzi Scheme requires resident
high priests for psychological sanctification. Despite
my criticism of his failed economic principles, Friedman made
some comments on Europe worthy of retort.
The parenthetic responses are by Bryan Rich of Weiss Research,
from their Money & Markets publication. The following
are comments by Friedman about a risk of fracture for the
Euro currency and implications to the European Union. See
the Money & Markets article entitled "Will the
Euro be the Most Hated Currency for 2010?" (CLICK
HERE).
A one-size fits all monetary policy does not give the member
countries the flexibility needed to stimulate their economies.
(The European Central Bank's mandate is inflation targeting,
not growth. A premature exit from easy money policies could
drive weaker European countries further into recession.)
A fractured fiscal policy forced to adhere to rigid EU rules
does not enable member governments to navigate their country
specific problems, such as deficit spending and public works
projects. (A majority of the sixteen countries in the monetary
union have completely disregarded the EU's Stability and Growth
Pact by running excessive deficits.)
Nationalism will emerge. Healthier countries will not see
fit to spend their hard earned money to bail out their less
responsible neighbors. (The cornerstone of the Euro, Germany, has rejected the notion of big spending
to bail-out troubled countries. And German citizens are in
a protectionist mode.)
A common currency can act as handcuffs in perilous times.
Exchange rates can be used as a tool to revalue debt and improve
competitiveness of one's economy. (Under the Euro, weak member
countries are helpless. Italy
has a history of competitive devaluations of the Lira during
sour times. Now, in the Euro regime, its economy is left flapping
in the wind.)
Today, the most challenging issue facing the Euro might be
addressed in this statement by Friedman: "Political
unity can pave the way for monetary unity. Monetary unity
imposed under unfavorable conditions will prove a barrier
to the achievement of political unity." He foresaw
the vulnerability of this single currency concept coming and
predicted the Euro's demise within a decade. Implications
extend to European political cohesion. The Euro has not outlasted
his prediction by much, only a year. If a sovereign debt crisis
defines 2010, look for the viability of the Euro currency
to come under attack again.